29 March 2022: Snape - A

What are the chances of Counsel accidentally at some point referring to the witness not as Doctor but as Professor?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

30 September 2022: Panel from minority ethnic communities - B

The second morning session was a general discussion. Counsel asked about any thoughts on them as patients coming from minority ethnic communities having an influence on their experiences of infected blood. The sense was one of there being some doctors who were paternalistic, while nurses were usually much more normal to be around. One felt she was treated like a child on some occasions. There were issues around language which let people down. The hierarchies seemed to be too fixed in their thinking. There was the sense of a white relative being given a better hearing when speaking up for the family than those who were not white. One witness now helps others from his cultural backgrounds to access local services. There was no offer of counselling to any of the families, and it was speculated that it was hard enough to overcome the language issues at the medical level, let alone when it might have been needed to provide a support service. The financial support schemes seemed to be anothe...
Read more

7 May 2025: Thomas-Symonds - A

Following on from the sight of a full panel of witnesses on the platform, the Minister sat in the middle of the long table looking as isolated a “Johnny No-mates”. There was no welcome as usually afforded the witness by the Chair, just a statement of the oath being administered. Before answering questions, the Minister, Nick Thomas-Symonds (NTS) wanted to make a statement. That was no surprise. After the obligatory latest apology, the statement was a combination of how short the timescales were (excuses), and how much he wanted to press ahead (oh really). Miss Richards reviewed how the so-called Expert Group had already done its work before he was appointed after the election. He was asked about the Inquiry findings related to the issue of a lack of transparency and candour by officials and how this had impacted the infected blood community. NTS was asked to confirm if the Government was committed to transparency and candour, and he said it was. It was pointed out that the timescale fo...
Read more

19 January 2023: Closing Statements, Katie Gollop KC (Haem Soc) - A

Katie Gollop KC confirmed that she was representing the Haemophilia Society (HS) and a number of named and unnamed individual core participants. She began by reviewing a selection of incidents experienced by her patient clients. These included the death of an eight-year-old whose parents discovered his viral status from a piece of paper on a hospital fridge door. The clinicians explained that they did not want to affect the relationship with their son by knowing. The other stories were equally harrowing, including the infection of people associated with the HS. In particular, the role of David Watters and his work with the HS was stressed as have being of great benefit to many people.   Not for the first time this closing statement began in earnest by quoting Bishop James Jones from his writing related to the Hillsborough disaster. The parallels were clear. The Cumberlege Report, “First Do No Harm”, was also cited. The “system is not good enough” was among the conclusions rel...
Read more